Your Product Is Competing With the Item Already on the Shelf

Most product pitches use the wrong competitive set.

The founder compares the product with brands that offer similar features. The deck shows specifications, prices, customer reviews, and a market map designed to prove differentiation.

The buyer is often making a different comparison.

Your product is competing with the item already on the shelf.

That incumbent has sales history. It has inventory in the system, reviews on the retailer's site, a place in the planogram, and a buyer who previously approved it. Even if it is not exciting, it is known.

Replacing it creates risk.

From the buyer's chair, the question is not only whether your product is better. The question is whether the assortment becomes better after the trade.

That requires five answers:

  1. What job does your product perform in the assortment?
  2. Which item, facing, or price point should lose space?
  3. What customer need is currently underserved?
  4. What evidence suggests the new item will outperform the incumbent?
  5. What happens if the thesis is wrong?

This is where Steven's operating perspective becomes important. Winning the argument is not enough. The brand must also prove it can supply the item, support the launch, maintain pricing, meet retailer requirements, and fund the test long enough to produce a readable result.

A useful buyer pitch should therefore include an incumbent page, not only a competitor page. Show the current assortment role, the proposed improvement, the expected productivity, and the operating plan behind the change.

Do not attack the incumbent. The buyer may have chosen it, and it may still be productive. Explain the trade with respect and precision.

The strongest sentence in the meeting is not, “We are different.”

It is, “Here is the specific part of your assortment we improve, the item we expect to outperform, and the evidence we are prepared to build together.”

Next step: Before your next buyer meeting, identify the incumbent and write the case for replacing it in one page.


Pressure-test it before the buyer does. A Channel Checkride Retail Readiness Review looks at your economics, assortment, and launch plan through the buyer's chair and the operator's chair. Request a Retail Readiness Review.

Related: The Jacket That Won Colorado and Failed Florida

Previous
Previous

Warranty Claims Can Strengthen an Outdoor Buyer Pitch

Next
Next

The Demo Unit Is Part of the Fitness Product